
Scotts Valley City Hall on Nov. 10. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/Report for America)
SCOTTS VALLEY >> A Scotts Valley Police Department employee is alleging Police Chief Jayson Rutherford sexually harassed, discriminated and retaliated against her in a lawsuit filed Sept. 29 in Santa Cruz County Superior Court.
The lawsuit details multiple incidents between 2024 and early 2026, including allegations of sexual harassment, groping and a power imbalance that, according to lawyers, led to retaliation. Referred to in the lawsuit as Jane Doe, she worked as an emergency dispatcher and Rutherford was her supervisor for approximately two years, according to the lawsuit.
Rutherford did not respond to repeated requests for comment. The defendants must respond to the lawsuit in court within 30 days of Nov. 5, according to Doe’s lawyer, Megan Mackie. According to the online court portal and Doe’s lawyer, Rutherford hasn’t yet provided a response.
Rutherford has been police chief since March, after serving as interim chief since November 2025. The Scotts Valley Police Department’s public information officer, Captain Scott Garner, did not respond to requests for comment.
Rutherford is being sued for sexual harassment, sex discrimination, retaliation, failure to prevent discrimination, harassment and retaliation, failure to provide reasonable accommodation and failure to engage in a timely, good-faith interactive process. The lawsuit also names the City of Scotts Valley, Scotts Valley Police and Rutherford as defendants.
The lawsuit alleges the city failed to thoroughly investigate Doe’s claims.
In a Nov. 11 email, Scotts Valley Interim City Manager Stephanie Hill stated that the city could not comment on the case, but said Rutherford continues to serve as chief. She added that the city “takes allegations of this nature seriously.”
Doe, who has worked as a dispatcher for Scotts Valley since 2017, shared details of her experiences in an interview with Santa Cruz Local last week.
“I’ve dedicated almost a decade of my life to this department, and it’s been really hard to reconcile that and everything that transpired,” she said. “It’s been a very tough journey and far from the end of it.”
Doe said that she was hesitant to come forward because of how small of a town Scotts Valley is.
“I never really imagined myself in this type of position, but I think that staying silent would have been a disservice to not only me but anyone in a similar situation to me,” she said.

Scotts Valley Police Department on 10. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/Report for America)
Lawsuit allegations against Rutherford
The lawsuit describes a flirtatious dynamic between Jane Doe and Rutherford that began in 2024 when he was her supervisor, and ended around December of last year.
While most of the conversations were consensual, according to the lawsuit, Rutherford’s position and authority created an unequal power dynamic between them. Things took a turn early this year after Rutherford entered a new relationship and stopped responding to Doe’s messages. After that, Doe alleges, Rutherford began avoiding her at work, treating her dismissively and excluding her from work conversations.
A large portion of the complaint discusses a job promotion that Doe ultimately did not get. Doe alleges she was overlooked for an emergency dispatch promotion in March, after another employee received the position despite having less work experience. Doe claims that she didn’t receive the job due to her sex, and her previous relationship with Rutherford.
According to the complaint, Rutherford was the one who made the final decision in the hiring process for the dispatch promotion. Doe is currently on disability leave and is looking for another job.
Additionally, the complaint describes two different physical encounters in 2025 between Rutherford and Doe. The first incident in the lawsuit occurred in March at a department appreciation dinner in Santa Cruz, when Rutherford allegedly brushed his arm against Doe’s breasts, pulled open the waist of her skirt and looked down at her underwear.
He then refused to walk her to her car because of how others at the dinner might perceive it, the complaint alleges.
The following month in April, Rutherford allegedly grabbed Doe’s buttocks multiple times at the gym they both attended. According to the lawsuit, Doe reported the encounter to a department officer that day, and told her supervisor, Chloe Graham, that she and Rutherford had been communicating for several months. Doe asked Graham not to repeat the information, and Graham agreed to keep it private.
Graham shared with Santa Cruz Local that she could not comment on the lawsuit or answer any questions, per the city attorney’s advice.
“I really hope that other women can take from this that you don’t have to tolerate this sort of treatment in the workplace, and that regardless of how it’s always been you can speak up and you should speak up because it will only empower others to do the same,” Doe said.
The lawsuit also discusses the city’s alleged refusal to accommodate Doe’s medical leave, which she sought due to work-related stress, depression and anxiety in April of this year. Doe remained on leave when the city launched an investigation into the harassment allegations against Rutherford.
According to the lawsuit, the city’s external investigator, who was hired to look into the sexual harassment allegations against Rutherford, denied Doe’s request to provide written responses to the ongoing investigation instead of participating in a live video interview in September. She was on medical leave at the time.
As a result, the city moved forward with its investigation of Doe’s complaints against Rutherford without hearing her testimony and only relied on the available evidence, according to the lawsuit. The current status of the city’s internal investigation is unknown.
Questions or comments? Email [email protected]. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.
As government accountability reporter, Erika Zaro brings in-depth, enterprise reporting on local institutions that affect residents’ everyday lives. Her stories examine major government decisions, track the promises of elected officials and investigate wrongdoing.

