The search to replace Superintendent Heather Contreras is set to be helmed by a contractor. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/Report for America)

WATSONVILLE >> Pajaro Valley Unified School District is planning to hire a contractor to lead its search for a new superintendent. 

Omaha, Nebraska-based McPherson & Jacobson was selected for the search, but a start date hasn’t been established. In a presentation to the board at a Nov. 9 meeting, the company stated it would find a suitable candidate for the job within 90 days.

Superintendent Heather Contreras is set to leave her post after her contract expires in June to become superintendent of San Luis Coastal Unified School District.

At the board’s Wednesday meeting, some people said they worry the contract is a bad use of funds, while most trustees said that hiring the firm will help gather community input while ensuring the best candidate can be found.

“I’ve been hearing in the community a lot about wanting transparency and wanting community involvement, and that’s exactly what these search firms will help the board do,” said Trustee Olivia Flores. “One thing our community needs to understand is that when you’re hiring a position at this level, there is a large amount of confidentiality involved.”

Stay informed on Santa Cruz County’s biggest issues.

Santa Cruz Local’s newsletter breaks down complex local topics and shows residents how to get involved.

Trustee Olivia Flores, right, and Superintendent Heather Contreras at a meeting in 2025. Both are set to leave their positions in the district in 2027. (Amaya Edwards — Santa Cruz Local/CatchLight Local file)

The firm said the cost of the search is not to exceed $28,100 and is hiring two California representatives to lead the effort: Vallejo-based lead consultant Nicole Anderson and Danville-based consultant Daniel Moirao. The company said it has conducted over 1,100 successful superintendent searches across 45 states.

“The people that gave me feedback said, ‘why are we spending money on this when we could hire from the inside and look at internal candidates as a board?’, which is our duty,” Trustee Gabriel Medina said.

During the meeting, Medina sought to add an amendment to the contract that would require the firm to look at internal applicants before extending the search for outside personnel, but the effort did not receive support from the rest of the board.

To guide the search, the company said it will work with the board to establish priorities and goals for the incoming superintendent’s first year. Possible criteria for a candidate could also include a focus on fiscal recovery and enrollment decline and an ability for multilingual community engagement, the firm said.

Flores addressed Medina’s concerns that the contract would limit the incoming board’s ability to make decisions. 

“I just wanted to assure the board that this search form will work for you, so whatever you would like them to do, they will work with the board,” she said.

She also said that she’s heard community members call for public input on the decision, but that guaranteeing confidentiality for candidates might limit how much the public can weigh in on the decision.

“There are probably some candidates who would be willing to be interviewed by community members, and this particular search firm has agreed to explore how that might be possible in conducting it so that it protects the anonymity and the privacy of the candidate, but it might not be possible to get the best candidate.” Flynn said.

Flynn also highlighted that it was McPherson’s focus and experience in gathering community inputs that made it the top candidate for the role.

The board voted 4-0-1 to move forward with hiring McPherson & Jacobson.

While Medina ultimately abstained from the vote, he indicated that the discussion had given him some reassurance. “What I’m hearing right now is that we’re approving the firm, but the next board gets to give direction as to what’s going to happen.”

Questions or comments? Email [email protected]. Santa Cruz Local is supported by members, major donors, sponsors and grants for the general support of our newsroom. Our news judgments are made independently and not on the basis of donor support. Learn more about Santa Cruz Local and how we are funded.

Learn about membership
Santa Cruz Local’s news is free. We believe that high-quality local news is crucial to democracy. We depend on locals like you to make a meaningful contribution so everyone can access our news.
Learn about membership

Alonso Daboub joins Santa Cruz Local as a California Local News Fellow. He earned a master’s degree in Science Communication at UC Santa Cruz.